Urban Decay Naked Basics vs. Naked 2 Basics vs. Pulp Fiction
When I was looking at the Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics palette, I pondered the question, which palette is best for me between the Urban Decay Naked Basics vs. Naked 2 Basics vs. Pulp Fiction? So I created a video to look at and compare all 3 palettes. Can you guess which palette comes out on top?
Urban Decay Naked Basics vs. Naked 2 Basics vs. Pulp Fiction
See my Naked Basics, Naked 2 Basics, and Pulp Fiction reviews.
If you like this video please share and subscribe!
Price
Pulp Fiction is more expensive at $34 for 4 eyeshadows (one is split into 2 shades, making 5), but you’re getting .06 oz x 4. (total .24 oz)
Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics are $29 each for 6 eyeshadows, each shade is .05 oz. (total .30 oz)
You end up getting more product for the price with the Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics.
Packaging
The Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics palette are more sturdy than the Pulp Fiction, though it’s no slouch.
I’m declaring the Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics the winners of this category.
Number of Shadows
Pulp Fiction has 5 distinctly different shades.
Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics both have 6, but some shades are quite similar.
You end up getting more variety with the Pulp Fiction palette.
Highlighters
I like Venus, though I also really like Furious. Skimp is darker than what I prefer for a highlighter shade. It blends into my skintone.
I’m declaring both Venus and Furious as winners here.
Base or Lid Shades
I’m not a fan of Foxy, too yellow on me.
I love Walk of Shame nd I’ve even hit pan on it. It’s a pale peachy pink matte.
I really like Righteous! It’s an awesome light peach beige.
Stark is sort of a peachy brown matte, not my favorite between these shades.
Walk of Shame has been a favorite of mine for 2 years. Righteous is a new favorite.
WoS and Righteous come out on top in this set.
ALL THE TAUPES!
Naked 2 is a light milky brown taupe.
Frisk is a light grey brown taupe.
Cover is a reddish brown taupe.
Primal is a deeper brown taupe.
I’m not a fan of any of these shades. I prefer my taupes very grey-toned.
Pulp Fiction comes out ahead of Naked Basics and Naked 2 Basics in this category.
Darkness and Depth
Faint is a deep brown with a hint of taupe to it. It’s ok.
Crave is a dark blackened brown. LOVE THIS!
Undone is a smoky deep taupe. I really like it.
Tyranny is a warm caramel brown. This is surprisingly flattering on me.
Vengeance is a dark brown. I like this shade.
Anger is a black. This is useful.
While I love Crave and Undone, I actually find all 3 of the deeper shades from the Pulp Fiction palette to be useful for me.
Pulp Fiction is first here while Naked Basics is a close second.
My original Naked Basics palette tutorial.
Another Naked Basics palette tutorial.
Pulp Fiction Palette tutorial.
My upcoming Naked 2 Basics palette tutorial.
Between the three palettes it’s easy for me to eliminate the Naked 2 Basics from the running because I don’t feel like I’ll get a lot of use out of Frisk, Cover and Primal. While I really like Undone, it doesn’t outweigh those 3 shades. Skimp is ok, but not really as a highlighter on my skintone. Stark is ok.
I primarily use Crave, Walk of Shame and Venus from the Naked Basics Palette. I’ve never figured out a use for Foxy. I’ve rarely used Naked 2 and Faint.
I’m surprised to say that the Pulp Fiction Palette wins between the three of these for me! Naked Basics takes second and Naked 2 Basics comes in third.
See my UD Naked Smoky vs. Silk Naturals Bare Necessities Smoky Comparison. See my UD Naked Smoky vs. Kat Von D Innerstellar Comparison.
Which palette is the right one for you? Let me know below!
Hi chica. I’ve had this post open for about three weeks now. I want my “ideal” small matte/satin/neutral palette, darnnit! The Pulp Fiction palette would suit me best, but I went the superficial route and got the sleek & small Naked Basics palette with the Sephora gift card. [Thanks again!] Well, whaddayaknow. I was unhappy with NB’s lack of a warm brown. My ideal would’ve been NB with PF’s Tyranny instead of Faint. I prefer to keep my eyeshadow stash spare so I played with using my Too Faced Chocolate Soleil Bronzer for the crease. BUT. I got greedy and got the PF palette after you tweeted about the price slash. Woo hoo! Now I think I have all the browns I’ll ever need. 🙂
By the way, I grin every time you lament over Foxy. I think I’ve seen you do that on your blog, in a few videos, *and* on Temptalia. Heh heh. If you ever choose to depot that shadow, send it right over. I get a good base colour when I mix Foxy with WOS. Later, Skater. 🙂
Edit: Scratch the above re: getting rid of Faint. Upon more reflection, it’s a toss up between Faint and Naked 2. Err… or maybe My ideal palette would be a 7-pan NB with Tyranny.
Ok. I’m back –>
I am a perfectionist and gee, I get an itch in my lower back when I see that square Tyranny pan . I really really really wanna find an empty UD pan so I can repress Tyranny and replace Faint with it. I also wish all the PF eyeshadows were the same shape as the NB eyeshadows. (I depotted the PF e/s, but in such a way it’s easy to pop ’em back in the original packaging.) Better yet, the next best thing to that 7-pan palette would be to get someone’s discarded NB palette to house repressed PF eyeshadows.
*groan* I tell you too much. I’m a freak!
LOL! Ok glad you picked up the Pulp Fiction palette on sale! Yes you’ve got all the browns now 🙂
Nix everything I wrote about the pans/packaging/perfect palette. I wore the PF palette last night. Beautiful shadows. And, because it was the best eye makeup I’ve ever done, here’s what I used: Tarte New Taupe pencil; Kat Von D Trooper liquid eyeliner; Chantecaille Sel; NARS Light-Reflecting Setting Powder, and… drumroll… UD Furious, Venus, Naked 2, Tyranny and a touch of WOS + Foxy!
My fiancé told he liked it. Unsolicited! That’s a big deal.
UD Naked Basics and UD Pulp Fiction palettes are fantastic! 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀
I just can’t make Foxy look good on me. Walk of Shame yes. Foxy… it’s like horrid on me
So glad to see this comparison. I was considering Naked2 Basics and now I know it is not for me.
Same Rebecca, just looking at the swatches, it looks like Naked Basics 2 is the nicest…I wasn’t really looking at the Pulp Fiction just between Naked 1 and 2 Basics.
Thank you for this comparison! I feel like I don’t need the Naked 2 Basics anymore after seeing this.
Hey Phyrra, thanks for the comparison! I don’t own any of these because I don’t use matte that often. I always need maybe one as a transition shade, but that’s about it. Since I already own several in different palettes, I decided to pass. I do agree with you that Pulp Fiction looks like the best out of the three though!
Waw ! Those eye makeups are gorgeous !
Xoxo
Michelle
I would want the Pulp Fiction one most!
I thought the Naked 2 Basics was more cool-toned but seeing swatches I’m not so sure. I think the Pulp Fiction palette is probably the best for me out of these three, but I wonder if it’s too similar to my UD Theodora palette? Might be able to save my money 😛
For me, it’ll probably the first Basics palette. I think the colors in Naked 2 are just a little too similar!
How about if someone doesn’t have the Naked 1 or 2, which would you recommend? I’ve got a more yellow undertone, so I think warm shades are better for me, but I do like the matte-colours of the Naked 2 Basics.
SO excited for this. I feel like I’ll love Basics 2 more than 1!
This is such a cool comparison! 😀 I have to admit, I’m tempted by the Naked2 basics, but only for 3 of the shades, which means I’m not sure if it’s really worth it..
So glad you find it helpful! I know that (to me) the 3 palettes seem similar on the surface, but when you dig a bit, they’re different.
I have all the Naked larger palettes so I’d probably get the pulp fiction.
It’s so cute
I’m an original Naked Basics girl.
I love it 🙂 Walk of Shame is awesome
What a fun post! I didn’t realize the Pulp Fiction palette had so many common shades.
I don’t have any of these palettes. Pulp Fiction I might buy just because I like the movie
I think you would come up with some awesome looks with Pulp Fiction!
I haven’t tried the Pulp Fiction palette but I have Naked Basics for myself & in my kit. Although I just realized that Crave shattered and got all over the other shadows… I might replace it with Naked 2 Basics
Oh no! I love Crave, it’s one of the best in that palette
I absolutely did not like Pulp Fiction. Sometimes I feel like the only person in the world who didn’t like it! However, I do like the palette 🙂
Aww, sorry you didn’t enjoy it!
I never bought the first Basics. I want Pulp Fiction for sure
I guessed Pulp Fiction but I still am surprised. Your bottom eye look is gorgeous.
Thank you! I will hopefully get the tutorial up soon
Although I am not a UD Naked fan for myself, I like the colors and the looks you created are pretty as well.
Thank you!
Seems like you could get the same variety from basics 1 as pulp fiction!
I was going to buy Pulp Fiction and then i heard rumors about N2 Basics. Between those two I think I would probably choose N2 Basics, mainly because it has all the cool shades I love from Naked 2.
I think I need Pulp Fiction just because PULP FICTION. I want Naked Basic 2, the first one was a fail for me.
I will need to buy all to see which one i like the best! lol
LOL! Tell Matt he better get shoppin’ for you.
Fabulous post!! I love the look you did with Naked @–can’t wait to see what you used under your lower lashes!
It’s UD Haight
wow really awesome comparison! while I like the colors of the pulp fiction more (with the exception of tyranny), I’d have to choose naked 1 due to more solid & slimmer packaging.
It’s a great choice 🙂
I like the Pulp Fiction one, but I’m bummed that the two most useful shades are halved! They should get their own pan. I actually really like the taupe shades from Naked 2, but I’d need to swatch them on my skin. Naked 2 should have eliminated one of the taupes and added a black similar to Crave, though. That would make it a much more useful palette, I think.
The taupes might work really well for you!
I have Naked Basics but really wanted a warmer brown. Is it just me or does anyone else find Naked Basics a teensy tiny bit cool? When I saw your tutorial for Pulp Fiction and got to see Tyranny in action, I was sold! I can’t wait to get the Pulp Fiction palette. <3
I think the naked 2 basics is cool toned, but it’s not icy cool. The original basics sort of reads as neutral to warm to me
If I had to choose between these three then I think I would like Naked Basics most.
You can certainly create some flattering looks with it
Is there a “none of the above” option?! LOL I’ll take Naked 2, to complete my Naked 1 and 3 collection!
Naked 3 is awesome!
I agree with your comment that the Naked Basics 2 shades seem a bit muddy, won’t suit my coloring either.
I know people rave about those shades, but I just can’t get them to work either.
Definitely the Naked Basics 2. I am plotting how to get it.
Yay for plotting!
Wow. Until you did this post it hadn’t even crossed my mind how similar the Naked Basics is to the Pulp Fiction (maybe because I don’t own either). I was never interested in the Basics palettes, but now that the second one has come out, not only am I interested in that, but also the first. Funny how that works. 🙂
I’m so glad that you found it useful! I figure they’re all 3 around the same size, and close to the same price point, and similar shades, so it would be helpful to compare them all.
Wow, what a super helpful comparison, Phyrra! So thorough! I didn’t have any interest in the Pulp Fiction palette initially, but you’re definitely tempting me 🙂
Righteous is definitely pretty 🙂
I’m going to finally break out my Naked Basics palette that I still haven’t even used plus I just bought Viseart Neutral Matte palette that is gorgeous, so I will pass on the new one but I imagine it will do well at any rate. Thanks for the great review of the 3
You need to give it a try!
would love the pulp fiction! love that movie!
Great movie!
OOPS! ;p Misread the blog in my haste! HA HA I thought it said the regular Naked 2 Palette. So to correct my choice it would be Naked Basics, Naked Basics 2, then Pulp Fiction.
Naked Basics is so useful!
I’m going in the opposite direction from you! ;D I choose the Naked 2 Palette first because I need to have some shimmer in my life and I like the variation in colors!!! ;D Next would be the Naked Basics 2 for the mattes, because we need them too! The Pulp Fiction would be my last choice because I could live without Tyranny ,it is too warm for me (HA HA I think I made a joke there without even trying!!! HA HA I also love your photo holding the 3 palettes. It is the look all of us girls get when we have to choose from our stash of goodies!!! 😀 😀 😀
I’ve been loving what I see of the Pulp Fiction palette, so I’m definitely going to have to check it out. I was expecting Naked Basics 2 to steer a different direction. But let’s hope if UD does a third edition they’ll pick a different scheme.
I hope for a 3rd for shades of grey (but not 50!)