This post may contain affiliate links. Purchasing through affiliate links help support this website.

Makeup Wars Best Black Eyeliners

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners

Happy Makeup Wars Monday! This time we’re sharing our picks for the best black eyeliners. Black is the eyeliner color that I wear more than anything. Lately, I tend to prefer my liner to be on the upper waterline or tightlined, rather than along the upper lash line. All eyeliners mentioned are cruelty free. Products that I know to be vegan are denoted as such.

PR + purchased by me.

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners

My go-to gel-like liner that I reach for more than any other is NARS Eye Paint in Black Valley. I bought Black Valley at the Makeup Show Orlando and have been in love ever since. For whatever reason, it’s the product that lasts the longest on my waterline and works best with my personal body chemistry and allergy-prone, sensitive, watery eyes. It doesn’t come off on my contacts or cloud my vision when my allergies are severe. If you only try one black liner from this list, I would say try Black Valley.

Two other gel-like eyeliners are Urban Decay Super-Saturated Ultra Intense Waterproof Cream Eyeliner and Inglot AMC Eyeliner Gel Matte 77.

You can apply gel eyeliners with a bent eyeliner brush (like the one by Makeup Geek or Sonia Kashuk) or with an angled brush like the UD Perversion brush. If you want to apply right at the lash line, you need a push brush like the goss 08.

When it comes to using any eyeliner, especially the gels or cremes, less is more. Definitely start out with a small amount and work up to the opacity you need. Don’t overload your brush. If you have hooded eyes, like I do, you need to use the least amount of liner possible to prevent creasing or transfer. And of course, always make sure to use eyeshadow primer.

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners

For precision cat eyes, I often like to use Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner in Perversion and Jesse’s Girl Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner pen. The UD has a flexible tip, like a fine paint brush. The Jesse’s Girl has a calligraphy style pen.

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners Swatches
L to R: UD Cream, NARS Black Valley, Inglot 77, UD Perversion, Jesse’s Girl, Sugarpill Bulletproof

Sugarpill Bulletproof is great for tightlining. I use my goss 8 brush to tightline with both Bulletproof and Black Valley.  It’s easy to use this brush to wiggle right at the root of the lashes or the upper waterline.

You can also use Bulletproof on top of other black products to help set them if need be. Or, you can even smudge Bulletproof this on top of a black pencil.

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners

There are a handful of black pencils that I like. The top three are Tarte Onyx, NARS Via Veneto and UD All Nighter. These stick around really nicely for me. Tarina Tarantino Tommy Jet and and Mally Beauty Black Velvet are also nice. Finally, I list OCC Tarred, because many people love it. I prefer this for my lips, but I love that it’s multi-purpose and you can use it for eyes, lips or anywhere else on the face and body.

Best Cruelty Free Black Eyeliners Swatches
L to R: UD All Nighter, Mally Black Velvet, OCC Tarred, NARS Via Veneto, Tarte Onyx, Tarina Tarantino Tommy Jet

One thing that I’ve noticed, as far as pencils go, with my oily eyes I tend to do better with dry pencil formulas like Via Veneto and Onyx.

Best Black Eyeliners

  1. NARS Eye Paint in Black Valley
  2. Urban Decay Super-Saturated Ultra Intense Waterproof Cream Eyeliner
  3. Inglot AMC Eyeliner Gel Matte 77
  4. Urban Decay 24/7 Waterproof Liquid  Eyeliner in Perversion (vegan)
  5. Jesse’s Girl Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen
  6. Sugarpill Bulletproof (vegan)
  7. Urban Decay All Nighter Eyeliner (vegan)
  8. Mally Beauty Evercolor Starlight Waterproof Eyeliner in Black Velvet
  9. Obsessive Compulsive Cosmetics Colour Pencil in Tarred (vegan)
  10. NARS Larger Than Life Longwear Eyeliner in Via Veneto
  11. Tarte skinnyEyes Amazonian Clay Eyeliner in Onyx (vegan)
  12. Tarina Tarantino Eye Dream Hyperliner in Tommy Jet
Wearing Black Valley on my upper waterline
Wearing Black Valley on my upper waterline. See the Electric Palette Tutorial.
Orange is the New Black Flaca Makeup Tutorial
Wearing Black Valley and Onyx, smudged.
Maleficent Eyeshadow Tutorial
Mally Black Velvet on waterline. See the Maleficent Movie Poster Inspired Tutorial
NARS Via Veneto
NARS Via Veneto and Black Valley. See the Tutorial.
UD Cream eyeliner on the waterline. See the Tutorial.
UD Cream eyeliner on the waterline. See the Tutorial.
NARS Black Valley with UD Blackheart smudged on top. See the Tutorial.
NARS Black Valley with UD Blackheart smudged on top. See the Tutorial.

Really, for a gorgeous combination, use NARS Black Valley and smoke any eyeshadow on top. Black Valley will act as a primer for the eyeshadow and give it a soft, modern quality. I love how it looks when I do this. Make sure you line the upper waterline with Black Valley too, so that your eyes stand out.

What cruelty free black eyeliners make your ‘best of’ list? Let me know below!

 Loading InLinkz ...

 

Last Updated on

Share

31 Comments

Comments are closed.