This post may contain affiliate links. Purchasing through affiliate links help support this website.

Favorite Makeup Geek Eyeshadows

Favorite Makeup Geek Eyeshadows

Favorite Makeup Geek Eyeshadows

I often get asked what are my favorite eyeshadows from Makeup Geek. So here are my favorite Makeup Geek eyeshadows. They have so many colors to choose from! I think they have over 145 pressed eyeshadows, 16 glitters and 8 loose pigments.

PR + purchased by me.

Makeup Geek eyeshadows are cruelty free, talc free and made in the USA. Get 10% off at Makeup Geek with code PHYRRA!

$6 regular
$10 foiled

Favorite Makeup Geek Eyeshadows

Big Palette
  • Row 1 Sugar Rush – Kaleidoscope – Sorcery – Concrete Jungle – Vanilla Bean – Barcelona Beach – Corrupt
  • Row 2 Phantom – Hot Pants – Masquerade – Caitlin Rose – Carnival – Motown – Duchess
  • Row 3 Prism – Wild Fire – Sorbet – Petal Pusher – Beaches & Cream – Tuscan Sun – Cherry Cola
  • Row 4 Limelight – Legend – Mermaid – Houdini – Peacock – Mai Tai
Left 9 pan is MannyMUA.
  • Row 1 Aphrodite – Mars – Insomnia
  • Row 2 Frappe – Sora – Cosmopolitan
  • Row 3 Luna – Beaches & Cream – Artemis
The Right 9 pan is
  • Row 1 Americano – Confection – Whimsical
  • Row 2 Pegasus – High Wire – Starry Eyed
  • Row 3 Center Stage – Typhoon – Poolside

You can see swatches of all my favorites

I really wish that Makeup Geek would make Mars and Insomnia (pressed) permanent. I’d also love to see Sugar Rush, Kaleidoscope, Prism and Wild Fire come back again in their pressed format, though the loose is nice too. I especially love how Kaleidoscope looks when worn.

Makeup Geek eyeshadows are sold exclusively at

What are your favorite Makeup Geek eyeshadows?

Tags from the story

1 Comment

  • I adore Hodini, Tuscan Sun, all the shadesin the Manny MUA palette are my favorites. I agree, Mars and Insomnia are amazing. I use Insomnia as an outer crease all the time, Mars in the crease is such a beautiful reddish burgundy, and I love Cosmopolitan as well. Actually, I created a great look by accident because last time I traveled some of it came out, and so I had some on my fingers and I used it to finish my eye , the red look I shared. Insomnia is just so pigmented as well, would you consider it a duochrome? I totally agree I hope they do make them permanent! I would love to check out all those other shades you mentioned too! By the time I got over to the Makeup Geek sale, most everything was sold out, but ofc the prices are still great. Definitely going to grab one of the Porcelain highlighters too. I love them all, but especially the light purple toned shade

Comments are closed.