I made a quick comparison between the Kat Von D Innerstellar vs. Urban Decay Naked Smoky palettes due to overwhelming request. Both of these palettes are cruelty free.
Pr + purchased by me.
Kat Von D Innerstellar vs. Urban Decay Naked Smoky
The KVD contains 4 brown shades that I feel are nearly identical and I won’t ever use. The UD palette has 2 brown shades that I won’t ever use. So by that comparison alone, there are more shades in the UD that I prefer to the KVD. The KVD has 6 in particular that I really like – Moonshine, Dios, Darkstar, Gravitron, Astrological and Lunacy. The KVD has a true purple – Lunacy. UD has 8 shades I really like – High, Dirtysweet, Combust, Thirteen, Slanted, Armor, Dagger and Black Market. I might come to love Smolder, even though it’s not a true purple. I really love that both have mattes. I love the cool tones, silvers and greys.
For me what it comes down to is – Kat Von D has 6 shades I really, really like and 4 shades I really, really dislike. I don’t like most brown eyeshadows. They go muddy on me and aren’t flattering.
Naked Smoky has 2 shades I dislike and the 8 shades I really like. So for me it’s more shades I like. Grey shades are more flattering on me.
You can see my First Look Video and Swatches of the Naked Smoky here.
You can see my first eyeshadow look, an everyday slightly smoky look here. I talk about the eyeshadow formula for the shades I wear in the look, which includes a few that I’m surprisingly disappointed in.
Which do you prefer between these two?