About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5: Is It a Dupe? (Swatches on Fair Olive Skin)
Hello beautiful people! Today I’m sharing About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5: Is It a Dupe? No. On my very fair olive skin, About Face The Performer Foundation in F2 Olive swatches warmer and deeper than Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5. The About Face Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive runs even deeper and greener than both. I swatched them side by side on my neck, chest, and arm so you can see for yourself.
I purchased all of the products in this post with my own money. Some links are affiliate links, and I may earn a small commission if you shop through them, at no extra cost to you. The entire reason I originally started my blog was because I wanted to find a foundation that matched me. 18 years later, here we are, I’ve found it in Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation Shade 2.5 Olive.
Where to Buy About Face
About Face, Douglas, Ulta
Where to Buy Lisa Eldridge
Lisa Eldridge
Where to Buy LYS and Haus Labs
Sephora
Products Featured
- About Face The Performer Skin-Focused Foundation in F2 Olive €27
- Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5 Olive €53
- About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive €25
- Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Concealer in 01 Fair Neutral $32
- LYS Triple Fix Blurring Skin Tint Foundation Stick in LN1 Porcelain Neutral $28
About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5: Is It a Dupe? (Swatches on Fair Olive Skin)
The Quick Verdict
View this post on Instagram
Watch the video on YouTube!
- About Face The Performer Foundation in F2 Olive (€27): warmer and deeper than Lisa Eldridge 2.5. Not a match for porcelain olive skin, but a promising shade for light olives a step or two deeper and warmer than me.
- About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive (€25): deeper, greener, and warmer than both foundations, including its own foundation twin. If you buy your Performer shade in the Illusionist expecting a match, you may be surprised.
- Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5 (€53): still the only true very fair olive foundation I’ve found, and the best match I’ve had in 30+ years. My full review is coming soon.
About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5: Side-by-Side Comparison
About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5 Olive Swatches
- About Face The Performer Skin-Focused Foundation in F2 Olive
- Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5 Olive
- About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive
- Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Concealer in 01 Fair Neutral
- LYS Triple Fix Blurring Skin Tint Foundation Stick in LN1 Porcelain Neutral
On my arm, from top to bottom: About Face The Performer Foundation in F2 Olive, Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in 2.5, About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive, Haus Labs 01 Fair Neutral Triclone Concealer, and LYS LN1 Blurring Foundation Stick. The depth and warmth difference between the two foundations is clear, and the concealer is the warmest, greenest stripe of the five.
- About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive
- About Face The Performer Skin-Focused Foundation in F2 Olive
- Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5 Olive
- LYS Triple Fix Blurring Skin Tint Foundation Stick in LN1 Porcelain Neutral
- Haus Labs Triclone Skin Tech Concealer in 01 Fair Neutral
On my chest and neck, from left to right: About Face F2 Olive Illusionist Concealer, About Face F2 Olive Performer Foundation, Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in 2.5, LYS LN1 Triple Fix Blurring Skin Tint Foundation Stick, and Haus Labs 01 Fair Neutral Triclone Concealer. I always match complexion products to my neck and chest rather than my face, because rosacea gives my face a red overtone that I want foundation to neutralize, not match.
You can see both About Face swatches sit as distinct warm bands against my skin, while Lisa Eldridge 2.5, LYS LN1, and Haus Labs 01 melt in.
Why F2 Olive Isn’t a Dupe for Lisa Eldridge 2.5
Both shades are genuine fair olives, which is why the comparison matters: they’re currently the only two Western foundations deliberately built for this undertone at the fair end. But they’re calibrated for different people. Lisa Eldridge 2.5 Olive is a muted grey-green cool olive that works at the porcelain end of fair. About Face F2 Olive carries more warmth and more depth, which pushes it out of porcelain territory entirely.
If you’re a light olive who finds Lisa Eldridge 2.5 slightly too pale or too cool, About Face F2 Olive could be lovely on you, and at €27 it’s worth a swatch. It extends the fair olive category rather than duplicating it. It just isn’t built for the palest of us.
Note that this is a shade comparison based on swatches. I haven’t fully wear-tested F2 Olive yet, so I can’t speak to its longevity or oxidation in that shade. However, I have wear-tested The Performer formula in F0 Cool (a fair cool shade that unfortunately turns a bit lilac on me), and I love the formula itself. It claims 12 hours of wear, and it lives up to that claim on my skin.
About the Concealer Mismatch
The finding that surprised me most: About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive doesn’t match The Performer Foundation in F2 Olive. The concealer runs deeper, warmer, and greener than the foundation wearing the same shade name. If you’re shopping this line, don’t assume your foundation shade translates to the concealer. Swatch both.
So What IS a Dupe for Lisa Eldridge 2.5?
As far as I can tell after swatching my collection: nothing, yet. The closest colour relatives I’ve owned are Missha M Perfect Cover BB Cream in 17 and 21, which share the grey-green muted logic, but they’re BB creams, not comparable formulas. My full Lisa Eldridge Shade 2.5 review is coming soon and will have more details!
Which Shade Should I Get Instead?
If F2 Olive is too warm and deep for you (hello, fellow porcelain olives, aka ghost olives 👻🫒), your answer is Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation in Shade 2.5. It’s the only foundation I’ve found that’s genuinely calibrated for very fair olive skin, with a muted grey-green cool olive tone instead of warmth. Yes, it costs twice as much. It’s also the best match I’ve had in 30+ years, so for me the math works.
If F2 Olive sounds like it could fit you, meaning you’re a light olive a step or two deeper and warmer than porcelain, or Lisa Eldridge 2.5 has ever run too pale or too cool on you, then F2 Olive at €27 is absolutely worth a swatch. This isn’t a bad shade. It’s a good shade for a different fair olive than me.
If F2 Olive runs too pale on you, good news: About Face built olive shades throughout The Performer’s 45-shade range, and Lisa Eldridge carries true olive shades at every depth of her range too. Olive is finally a real category at both price points, not a single token shade.
And if you’re not sure which fair olive you are, do what I did: swatch your current best-match foundations along your jawline, photograph them in natural light, and email Lisa Eldridge’s free shade match service. A real makeup artist looks at your photos and recommends a shade, and they offer a replacement if it’s wrong. That service is how I ended up correctly matched after three decades of guessing.
About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5 FAQ
Is About Face F2 Olive a dupe for Lisa Eldridge 2.5?
No. On very fair olive skin, About Face F2 Olive swatches warmer and deeper than Lisa Eldridge 2.5 Olive. They’re both fair olive shades, but for different depths of fair.
Who is About Face F2 Olive good for?
Light olive skin tones a step or two deeper and warmer than porcelain. If Lisa Eldridge 2.5 runs too pale or too cool on you, F2 Olive is worth swatching.
Does the About Face F2 Olive concealer match the F2 Olive foundation?
No. The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive runs deeper, greener, and warmer than The Performer Foundation in the same shade name.
Is About Face cruelty-free?
Yes, About Face is cruelty-free and vegan.
Is Lisa Eldridge cruelty-free?
Yes, Lisa Eldridge is cruelty-free and vegan.
Is About Face The Performer Foundation fragrance-free?
No, this foundation contains fragrance.
Is Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation fragrance-free?
Yes, it’s fragrance-free and essential-oil-free.
What About Face shade matches Lisa Eldridge 2.5?
None. There is no exact dupe in About Face for Lisa Eldridge.
Final Thoughts
While I love the formula of About Face The Performer Foundation, F2 Olive is sadly not a shade dupe for Lisa Eldridge Seamless Skin Foundation 2.5 Olive. About Face The Illusionist Concealer in F2 Olive isn’t even a shade dupe for The Performer Foundation in F2 Olive, which was a rude awakening. So my verdict for the About Face F2 Olive vs Lisa Eldridge 2.5 dupe? Not a dupe. Not even close, other than they’re all in the olive family.
What do you think? Have you tried About Face or Lisa Eldridge? Let me know in the comments below!
