This post may contain affiliate links. Purchasing through affiliate links help support this website.

Yesterday I picked up 2 MAC Sheen Supreme lipsticks. From looking at various watches online, they were the two that I thought I’d like the best, Insanely It & Ultra Darling.

I made the mistake of going to the MAC counter at Dillard’s. This is the same place that gave me a hard time over returning the MAC makeup remover that I’d used once, the very next day. They tried to tell me that you couldn’t Back to MAC for a Sheen Supreme Lipstick, and that the rules had just changed. I pointed out they were permanent and they same price as the regular lipstick line, and they refused. So I said ok, purchased what I was going to purchase, and will most likely not go back to that location. Everything I can find online says that they should have accepted my Back to MAC products for one of the lipsticks. This really annoyed me. And if anyone  has any updated information on whether they should have accepted it or not, I would appreciate it.

Anyway on to the lipsticks!
Insanely It is described as a watermelon pink, but it comes across as a hot pink to me, hence why I had to have it.
Ultra Darling is described as a mid-tone yellow pink, but to me it seems to be more of a pink-coral when worn.


Ultra Darling is actually a shade I can see stashing in my purse so that I always have a lipcolor I can wear,  no matter what else I’m wearing. I feel like it’s a really flattering shade. I like the colors, the color payoff, and texture. I can’t speak about the wear yet, as I just swatched these and then wiped my lips off.

What do you think? Have you tried the MAC Sheen Supreme Lipsticks?

Products purchased by me. All opinions are my own.